
(Image Credit: https://goo.gl/images/tK38s7)
Copyright law has always been an issue on YouTube. It is mainly a result of YouTube and Google’s fear that a copyrighted piece of content will end up on YouTube and they will end up with the consequences, so YouTube has decide to push all of the consequences off to the creators. This has made fair use very important. If you don’t know what fair use is the U.S. Copyright Office defines it as “a legal doctrine that promotes freedom of expression by permitting the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances.” Which basically means that you are allowed to use a peice of content for “criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.” This is where YouTube’s copyright strike system comes in. Youtube’s copyright strike system allows a content owner to strike a video for copyright and YouTube will instantly flag the video. There is no chance for a response from the video owner. This has cause many issues, most recently the recent copyright strike of YouTube Creator Kyle Hansen also known as Bitwit. The video in question is “LYLE REACTS TO THE VERGE’S PC BUILD VIDEO”. The video features Kyle’s character called Lyle reacting to The Verge’s PC build guide. The Verge’s build, originally uploaded, September 13th, 2018, has many mistakes, and was removed from YouTube by The Verge. This resulted in many reaction videos, but after about a couple weeks it died down. This was until February 12th, 2019 when Vox Media, Inc, The Verge’s parent company, sent a strike to Kyle’s channel. This resulted many videos about YouTube’s copyright policy. With the end being when The Verge’s editor-in-chief Nilay Patel requested a retraction of the strike. (Nilay’s response: http://bit.ly/2CaZAAJ) My opinion is that Vox was wrong to not concider this fair use. While Bitwit’s video is not perfect, it is a reaction to a piece of content which is covered under fair use. While The Verge was wrong and it need to be talked about, no one at The Verge deserved to recieve death threats. People make mistakes, we should make sure that they know that it was a mistake and then move on. We should spend years talking about some small mistakes.
Image Credit: Screenshot from one of AT&T’s “just ok is not ok” commercials




